What Are the Three Main Ways to Appeal a VA Disability Claim?
Filing a Supplemental Claim
If you have new evidence that you believe may change the VA’s determination, you can file a supplemental claim to include it. The additional evidence must be both new and relevant. New evidence is that which the VA hasn’t previously considered, and relevant evidence is that which proves or disproves an element of your claim.
A VA reviewer will evaluate your previously submitted information in light of the new evidence to see if a new decision is warranted. The average processing time for supplemental claims is roughly 125 days.
Documents you can submit with a supplemental claim include the following:
- A new nexus letter strengthening the connection between your service and your condition
- An updated diagnosis from your doctor
- Additional “buddy statements” from family, friends, or fellow veterans supporting your claims
Asking for a Higher-Level Review
If you believe the initial determination was clearly incorrect based on the existing evidence, you can ask the VA to have a different senior evaluator review your case file to determine whether an error or a difference of opinion changes the decision.
The VA generally resolves higher-level reviews within 125 days. You or your attorney can also request an informal conference with the VA to call out any specific errors in its first decision, but doing so can extend the processing timeline.
The Board of Veterans' Appeals
You can submit a formal appeal to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals, or BVA, to contest the VA’s decision on your original claim, supplemental claim, or a higher-level review.
The BVA will assign a Veterans Law Judge to evaluate your case based on one of three review options:
- Direct review: This is the quickest available option. A judge will decide your appeal without a hearing, based solely on the information you’ve already submitted to the VA.
- Evidence submission: This option acts like a combined supplemental claim and direct review, allowing you to present new documents within 90 days of requesting a BVA appeal. The judge will decide your case without a hearing.
- Hearing: You and your attorney can present your case to the judge either in person or by video conference. You can submit new evidence during or within 90 days after the hearing.
Depending on the option, the BVA aims to resolve cases within one to two years. Because the timeline is much longer, BVA appeals are best used in cases involving complicated medical or legal issues, or as a last resort after other appeal options are exhausted.
What Happens if the Board of Veterans' Appeals Denies My Claim?
If the BVA makes a decision you’re unhappy with, and you don’t have any evidence to add in a supplemental claim, your only remaining option is to go outside of the VA’s administrative system by appealing to the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims. However, you have to act within 120 days of the BVA’s ruling, or you will lose your opportunity to continue your appeal.
An experienced veterans disability lawyer can explain what a federal court appeal will entail and help you decide the best path forward.
How Can a Lawyer Help With My VA Disability Appeal?
Rob Levine Law has been helping veterans get the disability benefits they’ve earned for more than a decade. As a former military police officer who served in the U.S. Army Reserve and Rhode Island National Guard, founder Rob Levine is dedicated to fighting for the rights of veterans like you.
Our trusted legal team has over 75 years of combined experience handling veterans disability claims. If you need help navigating the VA appeals process, we’re available 24/7 to take your call and answer your questions. With our Fee Free Guarantee®, you won’t pay us anything unless you win your case.
Contact us online or call (888) 791-9135 today for a free consultation.
If you have questions about your legal options after a dog bite, our dog bite lawyers are available 24/7 to help. Call (888) 791-9135 or contact us online to schedule your free consultation.